Aquarium Journal

You are currently browsing articles tagged Aquarium Journal.

One Year in Two Days

Two days after this picture was taken my tank will have been up for one year. And that pic was taken two days ago. So today makes 1 year! Yippee!!!

But this isn’t the anniversary photo. Maybe I’ll take that tonight. There have definitely been changes in the last two days.

It’s been a stable year for the tank. But a disappointing year in some ways too. And a year of learning.

The fish have been healthy. I did have one case of bloat in one of my discus. And I thought that I had lost most of my Ottocinclus catfish until I tried to put some Rotalla wallichii in the tank, and I caught them eating the tips. So I guess they are just hiding in the plants unless there is something really tasty to come out for. Same with my amano shrimp (cardinia japonica). I thought they were gone too, but when I did a big trim a couple of weeks ago, I found dozens of them. Hiding too I suppose.

I’ve struggled with algae in this tank. None of the bad varieties. Just green spot (GSA) on the plants and green dust algae (GDA) on the tank walls. Lots of “experts” will tell you that GDA in particular just means you have a healthy tank. But lots of people don’t have it at all. I don’t mind a little. A minor wall cleaning every week or two is fine. But in a 180 gallon tank, any more than that is work. And I’ve been working.

I’ve flirted with a number of fertilization dosing regimens, and have settled back on the one I started with: letting the N an P in my tap water supply those macros, coupled with that being produced by plants, excess food, and biological breakdown of plant matter, supplemented with daily potassium and limited daily micros. That seems to both keep my plants healthy, and keep away the thread algae that wants to appear in any of my tanks that have sand substrates coupled with Phosphates over 1.4 ppm.

Ultimately I think the reason why dosing normal levels of N & P did not work for me in this tank was that my plant mass to animal mass ratio could not sustain it. The ammonia excreted by the discus was not being utilized by the plants fast enough. The plants were being dosed good levels of nitrogen in my dosing regimen, and the ammonia (NH4) was not being used fast enough and was triggering algae growth. Not that you could measure any ammonia in my tank. But it doesn’t take much to encourage algae.

For the sake of my plant health - which keeps the algae at bay -I’ve had to make a compromise that really hurts. I’m adding small daily doses of baking soda (NaHCO3), Epsom Salts (MgSO4), and Calcium Chloride (CaCl2) to raise my KH and GH. I’ve gone to great lengths to make this tank as low maintenance as possible, with a reasonable degree of success. One major goal has to been to be free of daily maintenance - with the exception of fish feeding. But if I’m away, anyone can do that for me.

To accomplish that my ferts are injected automatically, and my water changes are done in small, daily, completely automated cycles. To that end I’ve tried to let my plants adjust to the extremely low KH and GH of my tap water, and it just hasn’t worked. They don’t thrive without more calcium and magnesium than my tap provides. And the baking soda helps keep the pH stable. So I’m stuck adding this stuff daily. So much for no daily maintenance. I’ll just have to figure out a suitable way to automate this too.

And finally, I’ve finally finished all of the technical changes to the equipment that supports the tank. I’ve not posted info on it yet, but a pretty elaborate setup support the tank. A year ago I still had an additional pump and filter to install, a few improvements to make to the plumbing, and I needed to move the “water depth sensor” tube to a different bulkhead opening in the bottom of the tank. With that last labor intensive item done this weekend, there are no more planned changes to the equipment under the tank.

So I find myself at the end of a moderately successful first year of this tank. The hardware supporting it is finished. I’ve got the algae under control. And have finally found plants that work well with these lights, at these fertilization levels, at the warm temperatures discus require.

On the down side, I’ve got to figure out a way to automate my daily GH/KH boosting. And I’m not happy with the aquascape. That will - no doubt - be the focus of my efforts this coming year.

PS - If you see the dark discus that appear to be sulking in the right corner, they aren’t sulking. They’re OK. They are just tending their eggs.

Had to trim - couldn't help it!

In my last journal post I said that I’d keep my hands out of the tank until the end of the month, when I passed the one-year mark for the tank. Well, those intentions were great… but I could not help myself.

Most of the stem plants were at the water’s surface, and I don’t want them to get too “leggy”. I’m not a good aquascaper, but if I have to hang on to stem plants to keep this tank healthy, I’d at least like them to be bushy and thick. So they were getting a bit too tall and I cut them.

Because I’ve been fighting excessive Green Dust Algae (GDA) on the tank walls for a number of months, and because it has been MUCH better in the last month or so, I’m worried about pulling too much plant mass out of the tank. So I took metal weights and wrapped them around the tops of the stems I trimmed, and sunk them back into the tank. So hopefully they’ll keep growing and plant mass will not be too adversely impacted by the trimming.

In the pic you can see that the Ludwigia repens to the left is not doing well at all. When I let it grow to the surface it is thrilled. But even nine inches lower than the surface and it starts to really suffer. Now, where I have it growing is not directly under the metal halides. This plant needs high light to thrive. But I’m hard pressed to believe that being 18″ from a 150 watt HQI lamp is not enough light to thrive. I just don’t buy it. Instead I think that when it gets really, really close to the light that the photosynthetic rate that results somehow gets beyond what ever else is holding it back.

I can’t be sure, but I suspect the problem is temperature. My temps fluctuate from about 81.5 to 83.5 during the day. And Ludwidgia - a native of North America - is a cool water plant. But supposedly it can tolerate warmer water. This is kind of my test.

Anyway… the some of the other stem plants I inserted to help with the GDA - Wisteria (Hygrophila difformis) and Green Temple (Hygrophilia corymbosa) - seem to be dealing with heat just fine. Since I’m personally fond of Ludwigia’s, I’d be really tickled if this gets healthy too.

Approaching 1 year

This is a shot of my tank from yesterday. I’m approaching the 1 year mark for having this tank up. By that I mean plants and fish in the tank. That day was May 27th, 2007. I keep really detail records on my tanks (something I heartily recommend to everyone), so I know that is the correct date. Yet I am frustrated by the fact that I STILL don’t have an aquascape that I’m happy with. But I’m going to have to just chill on that, because I’ve stated on some forums that if I haven’t gotten control of the algae I’m battling by the one year mark, then I’m scrapping the aquascape and starting over.

Well, as it turns out, the algae is reasonable right now. But it’s only been “OK” for a few weeks - apparently due to a radical change in my fertilization regimen. So while I’d love to rearrange plants so that I could say that I crossed the 1-year mark having achieved a satisfactory aquascape, I’m going keep my hands out of the tank for the next couple of weeks. If the algae remains under control as it is now, I won’t scrape the tank, but will merely rearrange it to a more esthetically pleasing arrangement.

If you saw my AGA 2007 post, you will see that I started this tank with anubias all over the driftwood. Those anubias got (and continue to get) green spot algae (GSA) on old leaves like nobody’s business. So I ripped those out and tried to replace them with other plants - primarily crypts of various forms. You will also note that I removed all the lovely lotus plants I was growing. Those were sending roots into the sand and causing what seemed (to me) to be unhealthy conditions in the sand. So I ripped them out. I never intended to have plants rooted in sand. All the plants you see right now are either not rooted in the sand, or they are in shallow pots of ADA Aquasoil covered with sand.

From the primarily anubias and lotus arrangement I moved to a (shallow potted) ’scape of various rosette plants. Those all suffered from the intensity of the 2 150w halogens. The algae it created on their leaves caused constant trimming until the plants were just dim shadows of the huge plants they started out as.

And next I filled the tank with stem plants as an algae fighting measure. The tank you see today is a reflection of that.

There are a number of urgent aquascape changes that need to be made to this tank . But I’m gonna let it cross the 1 year mark before I mess with it in a major way.

IMO a planted discus tank does not do well with hard tinkering or rapid changes. If it is balanced, leave well enough alone. Or tinker very slowly. So keep posted. A better tank is coming. I hope. But it will take a month or so.